For many viewers outside the UK,Downton Abbeyis the ultimate British TV show - especially when it comes to actually learning about the country and its culture. Julian Fellowe’s 2010-2015 period drama, with its grand estates, aristocratic family, and intricate social hierarchy, paints a lavish picture of early 20th-century Britain. However, while educational in its way, there’s a better option for Anglophiles who want a show that captures the UK as it truly is -Coronation Street(or, as we call it here in the UK,Corrie). Forfans of British TV who want to understand the UK,Downton Abbeyis an adequate teacher, but it’s not the best. That honor belongs toCoronation Street, the long-running British soap opera that has been airing since 1960.
UnlikeDownton Abbey, which explores a world that existed over a century ago,Coronation Streetis a contemporary, ongoing series that reflects modern Britain as I - an actual British person living in the UK - know it. And, since it’s been on the air for over 50 years, it’s captured a phenomenal amount of history (and its impact on the UK). WhileDownton Abbeypresents an idealizedand often romanticized past, which, as a UK citizen, I can’t relate to,Coronation Streetdelivers an authentic, evolving depiction of working-class life. From social issues to family struggles, from local politics to national crises,Coronation Streetprovides a window into the UK that is more accurate, relatable, and insightful than anythingDownton Abbeycould offer.
10 TV Shows You’d Be Shocked To Know Are Still Running
While many shows have famously continued for decades on end, viewers will be surprised to learn that others are still making new episodes.
Coronation Street Gives A Better Perspective Of British History
The Soap Beats The Historical Drama At Its Own Game
It’s easy to assume that a period drama likeDownton Abbeywould be a better resource for learning about British history, given that it is explicitly set in the past and follows real historical events. However, I’d always recommendCorrieoverDowntonto anyone who wants to learn about how Britain changed during the 20th century.Coronation Streetis actually far more effective at providing a long-term, evolving perspective on the modern history of the UK thanDownton Abbey.This is because the soap opera has been on the air for over six decades, chronicling real events as they happened and showing their impact on everyday British citizens.
Since its debut in 1960,Coronation Streethas tackled major historical moments that shaped the UK.The show has explored events such as the miners’ strikes of the 1980s, the rise and fall of Margaret Thatcher, the effects of the 2008 financial crisis, and even Brexit.These were not background elements or historical footnotes - they were woven into the lives of the characters, affecting their jobs, relationships, and futures in the same way they affected real people living in the UK at the time.
BecauseCoronation Streethas spanned generations, it also provides a sense of historical continuity.
In contrast,Downton Abbeyoffers a much narrower view of history.WhileDowntondoes touch on significant events- the sinking of the Titanic, World War I, the Spanish flu pandemic, and the decline of the British aristocracy - it does so through the lens of a wealthy, landowning family who are largely insulated from the struggles of ordinary people.The characters ofDownton Abbeyexperience historical events, but they do so from a position of privilege that does not reflect the experiences of most British people at the time.
What’s more, the events covered continue to shape UK society, but they aren’t the most impactful. The last timethe sinking of the Titanicwas truly relevant to UK life was in 1997, when James Cameron’sTitanicwas on almost every cinema screen. The First World War was also, of course, impactful, but nowhere near as much as the second.It took the UK decades to recover from WW2, andthe earliest seasons ofCoronation Streettake place during the post-war period which shaped the country I grew up and still live in.
BecauseCoronation Streethas spanned generations, it also provides a sense of historical continuity. Viewers can follow families over decades, watching how different political and economic shifts affect them.This intergenerational storytelling ofCoronation Streetoffers a much richer and more personal perspective on British history than the neatly packaged, aristocratic narratives ofDownton Abbey.
Coronation Street Portrays A More Authentic UK Community Than Downton Abbey
The Way Of Life In Downton Hasn’t Existed For Decades
Community may be at the heart of both shows, butCoronation Streetis a better teacher of British culture and communities thanDownton Abbey.The fictional neighborhood of Weatherfield, whereCoronation Streettakes place, is a working-class area that closely resembles countless real towns and communities across the UK.It captures the feel of a tight-knit, urban environment where everyone knows each other, for better or worse.
While picturesque,Downton Abbeyrepresents a way of life that was already vanishing by the time the series takes place.
In contrast,Downton Abbeytakes place in a grand estatein the English countryside, which is a far cry from how most British people live.While picturesque,Downton Abbeyrepresents a way of life that was already vanishing by the time the series takes place. Weatherfield, on the other hand, feels real. The houses are small, the characters deal with everyday concerns like rent and employment, and the local pub, the Rovers Return, is the beating heart of the community, much like real pubs in the UK.
Downton Abbey: 5 Most (& 5 Least) Realistic Storylines
Downton Abbey had a lot of drama, both upstairs and downstairs, but not everything that happened on the show was realistic for the time period.
The interactions inCoronation Streetreflect how people in small British towns actually live. Neighbors argue over parking spaces, gossip at the corner shop, and rally together in times of crisis. I know nobody remotely like anyDownton Abbeycharacters, but the residents of Weatherfield all remind me of someone I know from my local community.It’s a place where class divisions exist, but they are subtle and fluid, unlike the rigid upstairs-downstairs divide ofDownton Abbey.WhileDowntonfocuses on the interplay between the wealthy Crawleys and their servants,Coronation Streetpresents a more horizontal society, where people from different backgrounds live side by side and share common struggles - in other words, the way the UK truly is.
Downton Abbey Doesn’t Explore Class As Well As Coronation Street
Upstairs-Downstairs Is Far Too Simplistic
Social class is a fundamental aspect of society in the UK (just as much now as it was in the early 20th century) and bothDownton AbbeyandCoronation Streetengage with the theme in different ways. While it’s not as direct as it was during the time ofDownton Abbey,it continues to shape the culture of Britain. Any fans of UK TV who want to truly understand why my country is the way that it is need to understand the impact of class, really, as it shapes almost everything.This is where, once again,Corrieis my go-to recommendation, sinceCoronation Streetoffers a much more nuanced and relevant portrayal of class in modern Britain.
Downton Abbeyrevolves around the aristocracy and their servants, presenting a very traditional depiction of class division.WhileDowntondoes touch on social change, particularly with the decline of the landed gentry, it still romanticizes the idea of nobility.The Crawleys are presented as benevolent, fair-minded employers, and even the servants seem content with their lot, with only the occasional character challenging the social order.
The long-running soap does not shy away from depicting financial struggles, job insecurity, and the challenges of social mobility.
Coronation Street, on the other hand, is fundamentally about working-class life.The long-running soap does not shy away from depicting financial struggles, job insecurity, and the challenges of social mobility. UnlikeDownton Abbey, where characters rarely worry about money,Coronation Streetcharacters are often seen dealing with economic hardships, be it through redundancy, strikes, or financial scams.
Coronation Streethas also depicted a more fluid class structure that’s more authentic to Britain as it really is.Characters have risen and fallen in social status, reflecting the reality of social mobility in the UK.Factory workers become business owners, shopkeepers become politicians, and people’s fortunes change in a way that is far more reflective of modern British society than the rigid class structures ofDownton Abbey.
Downton Abbey Focuses On Too Narrow A Slice Of Life
The Narrow Ensemble Limits Perspective
One of the biggest limitations ofDownton Abbeywhen compared toCoronation Streetis its narrow focus.Downton Abbeycenters around an aristocratic familyand their immediate circle, which, while entertaining, does not reflect the broader British experience.Even in the early 20th century, whenDowntonis set, the Crawleys represented only a tiny fraction of the UK population. The middle class was already well established, and the working class made up the vast majority of the country.
Coronation Streetpresents a far more diverse and inclusive vision of Britain, and one that’s much more accurate.Over the years,Coronation Streethas explored stories involving immigrants, LGBTQ+ characters, and people from different racial and religious backgrounds. It has tackled issues such as homophobia, racism, domestic abuse, and mental health, reflecting the real challenges that people in the UK face.The soap’s long-running nature means that it has been able to evolve with the times, incorporating modern issues in a way thatDownton Abbey, as a historical drama, simply cannot.
Ultimately, whileDownton Abbeyis an engaging and well-crafted drama, it provides a limited and idealized view of the UK.
Additionally,Coronation Streetfeatures a wider range of professions and social classes.WhileDownton Abbeyis primarily concerned with the upper class and their servants,Coronation Streetincludes factory workers, shop owners, teachers, police officers, and small business owners.This breadth of perspective gives a much more comprehensive picture of UK society.
Ultimately, whileDownton Abbeyis an engaging and well-crafted drama, it provides a limited and idealized view of the UK. As much as I’d love to say that life in Britain really is mostly crumpets and tea parties, this sadly isn’t the case (apologies for the burst bubble). For viewers who truly want to understand the country - its history, its communities, and its people -Coronation Streetis the show to watch. With its long history, realistic characters, and ever-evolving storylines, it paints a far richer and more accurate portrait of British life thanDownton Abbeyever could.
