The highest-rated episode ofEvilshows exactly why season 5 of the canceled Paramount+ series needs to happen. Though no explanation was given by the streaming platform,Paramount+ announced thatEvilseason 4 would be the psychological mystery show’s final outing in 2024. Manyshows likeEvilhave been axed before their stories reach their natural conclusion. In the case ofEvil,the spine-chilling narrative was somewhat wrapped up during season 4 — though there are several avenues to explore if the series gets picked up by another platform.
Evil’s series finalefeatures the formal end of the Assessors, as well as the defeat of Leland (Michael Emerson). However, several of season 4’s plot threads could continue into season 5. Both the character conflicts and the main story could go forward — and considering the positive reactions audiences had to the series' four-season run, they should. The fact thatEvil’s highest-rated episode is one of its most recentis further evidence that season 5 needs to happen.

Evil Was The Spiritual Successor To An 87% RT Show That Also Got 4 Seasons, But Only 1 Had A Proper Ending
Evil comes off as the spiritual successor of an acclaimed supernatural show, which also has 4 seasons, but only only of the two shows has a conclusion
Evil’s Highest-Rated Episode Is One Of Its Most Recent
“How To Survive A Storm” Is At The Top Of IMDb’s Top-Rated List
Evil’s highest-rated episode is one of its most recent, showcasing how the series was at its creative peak before its abrupt cancelation.Evilseason 4, episode 10, “How to Survive a Storm,” is first on the series' top-rated list, boasting8.7 out of 10 starsonIMDb. The episode sees the Assessors taking down Leland with the help of Sister Andrea (Andrea Martin) during Hurricane Lucy. It creates new levels of tension and suspense, as well as a sense of victory that sets up the rest of the season nicely.
“How to Survive a Storm” shows the series' creative peak, but the fact that other season 4 episodes ofEvilare on the highest-rated list strengthens the argument for the series' renewal.

Having a season 4 episode as the show’s highest-rated highlights the strength ofEvil’s story plan.Leland’s manipulations perfectly set up how powerful he isand how the Assessors can only win against him using teamwork. The darker atmosphere and chilling sequences add to this installment, keeping audiences engaged as each character is faced with horrors with no real way out. “How to Survive a Storm” shows the series' creative peak, but the fact that other season 4 episodes ofEvilare on the highest-rated list strengthens the argument for the series' renewal.
Evil’s Top 10 Highest-Rated Episodes Further Prove Season 5 Must Happen
Half Of The List Is Made Up Of Season 4 Episodes
Out of a list of 10, five of the highest-rated episodes ofEvilare from season 4, further proving that season 5 must happen.Season 4, episodes 1, 7, 8, and 11 are listed alongside episode 10 as some of the best installmentsof the series. Each episode has an average of about 8.5/10 stars. These chapters mostly center on Leland and Timothy. However, they also feature some compelling mysteries for the leads, showcasing thatEvil’splot was expanding as the season went on.
DespiteEvilending, many of its fascinating storylines have not truly reached their conclusion.Kristen (Katja Herbers) and David’s (Mike Colter) move to Rome only complicates their fatesfurther, as the Vatican could easily catch wind of Timothy’s status as the Antichrist. That open-ended thread, alongside how it will affect the romantic tension between the two leads, is one of many reasons viewers likeSteven King are calling forEvilseason 5.Evilseason 4 showcased the possibilities and strength of the series, making its cancelation all the more tragic.

Evil
Cast
Evil is a psychological mystery series that follows a skeptical forensic psychologist, Kristen Bouchard, who teams up with a Catholic priest-in-training and a tech expert to investigate purportedly supernatural incidents. The series delves into complex themes of religion, science, and the nature of evil through its deeply layered narrative and character development. The show stars Katja Herbers, Mike Colter, and Aasif Mandvi.