Gary King may be a fan favorite onBelow Deck Sailing Yacht, but his past behavior proves he will never be trusted as a captain. Since his debut in season 2, Gary has gained a reputation for his wild partying, complicated boatmances, and questionable leadership skills. While his charm and experience make him an entertaining reality TV figure, they also highlight why he is too risky for a position of authority.
A captain is expected to lead by example, maintain professionalism, and ensure crew members' and guests' safety and respect. However,Gary’s history of excessive drinking,inappropriate workplace relationships, and alleged misconduct all suggest he falls short of these standards.His behavior on and off the show has raised serious concerns, proving that while he may thrive as a reality TV personality, he is far from the ideal candidate to be aBelow Deckcaptain.

Gary’s Reckless Behavior and Questionable Leadership
Gary has exhibited an inclination for excessive drinking throughout his time on the show. Notably, duringBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5, after a night of heavy partying, he threw something at Chief Engineer Davide Morosi, causing a cut to his face and staining a sofa with blood. This incident led to the crew losing their day off, andGary admitted to having no recollection of the events. In response,Gary committed to sobriety, a short-lived decision. In addition, Gary’s leadership and professionalism have been called into question. Several of his interactions with Captain Glenn Shephard have, at times, been perceived as disrespectful.
BDSY’s Gary Is Always Hooking Up With Someone New
Gary’s Never-Ending Love Triangles Disrupt the Crew
Gary’s romantic entanglements have become a defining aspect of his timeonBelow Deck Sailing Yacht. Season after season, he finds himself in love triangles and messy flirtations with fellow crew members. His inability to separate work from romance often creates unnecessary drama that distracts from the team’s ability to function smoothly.
These constant hookups have also led to tension and conflict among the crew. When emotions run high, it affects not just Gary but also those around him, making the yacht a toxic work environment. A captain must set a professional example, butGary’s track record suggestshe will welcome chaos rather than maintain order on board.

BDSY’s Gary’s Alleged Sexual Misconduct Is an Issue
The Reports Against Gary Raise Concerns About His Future on Below Deck
In August 2023, serious allegations emerged against Gary. Samantha Suarez, a former makeup artist for the show, accused him of sexual misconduct during the production ofBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 4. She alleged Gary forcibly held her against her will in his hotel room, an incident that was reportedly downplayed by the production team (viaPeople).
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Given these factors,promoting Gary to the position of captainwould be a considerable risk. A captain must exemplify professionalism, maintain clear boundaries, and uphold the safety and well-being of both crew and guests. Gary’s history suggests that he may not be suited to meet these critical responsibilities.

