Julia Roberts' co-star remembers her being mistreated by the director on the set ofSteel Magnolias. Directed by Herbert Ross, based on the 1987 play and adapted to the screen by Robert Harling, the 1989 film follows the close-knit bond between a group of women in a small Southern town and how they navigate the loss of one of their own. Themovie stars Julia Roberts, Sally Field, Dolly Parton, Shirley MacLaine, Daryl Hannah, Olympia Dukakis, Tom Skerritt, Dylan McDermott, Kevin J. O’Connor, and Sam Shepard.
In her new memoirThe Wall of Life(viaVariety),Shirley MacLaine remembered Julia Roberts being mistreated by director Herbert Ross on the set ofSteel Magnolias. She says the director mistreated and was unfair to Roberts, and seemed threatened by her talent and beauty. Eventually, the rest of the cast collectively urged the director to stop his mistreatment of the young actress. Read MacLaine’s full comments below:
He did not treat her well, and he was so unfair to her. Everyone else could see how talented and beautiful she was, so we didn’t take it too well. She seemed to threaten Herb Ross’ sense of power. We told him to knock it off and to leave her alone.
What Shirley MacLaine’s Comments Mean For Julia Roberts' Mistreatment On Steel Magnolias
They Corroborate Sally Field’s Recent Comments
Earlier this year,Sally Field also opened up about director Herbert Ross' mistreatment of Julia Roberts whilefilmingSteel Magnolias. In an interview, Field said the director was “very, very, very hard on Julia. If you ever talk to Julia, she’ll tell you.” Field continues, describing how the cast coalesced around the young Roberts, “We would all rally around Julia, because she was the baby. She was sort of the newcomer. And she was wonderful, and he just picked on her. It was awful.”
Julia Roberts' Upcoming Movie Can Finally Break A Surprising 10-Year Career Streak
Julia Roberts' upcoming film “After the Hunt” could be her ticket back to the Oscars after a 10-year hiatus. Roberts will showcase her range.
Field doesn’t see a particular reason why Roberts was mistreated, other than the director was “a real son of a bitch” and “some people just need to have somebody they pick on.” Field says it wasDolly Partonwho first turned on the director, “always with humor, but usually the most vulgar humor you ever heard so that it was like, you just literally don’t have a leg to stand on.” Field says she doesn’t “mind notes” as an actor, but what the director did to Roberts was just plain “mean.”
Our Take On Julia Roberts' Mistreatment On Steel Magnolias
There Was A Power Imbalance At The Time
There is an inherent power imbalance between directors and actors on film sets, and nowhere is that more apparent than onSteel Magnolias. At the time, Ross was known for directing 1977’sThe Turning Point, receiving Academy Award nominations for Best Director and Best Picture, and afterward, he went on to direct a big-box office success in 1984’sFootloose. On the other hand, 1989’sSteel Magnoliaswas one of Roberts' first credits, though she quickly made a name for herself by earning the first Oscar nomination of her career, signaling to future collaborators that she shouldn’t be messed with.
Julia Roberts' Performance Still Stands Out
For his stage play,Steel Magnolias, Robert Harling drew significant inspiration for the story from his sister, Susan Harling Robinson, who passed away in 1985 due to complications from type 1 diabetes. The play first premiered Off-Broadway in 1987 before he adapted it into a feature film in 1989. In the movie,Julia Roberts plays Shelby, the character based on Susan.Steel Magnoliaspremiered to mixed reviews, though Roberts' performance was widely praised, earning her first Oscar nomination.
Over 30 years later,Steel Magnoliasstill stands as an early testament to Julia Roberts' talent.
Steel Magnoliasreviews represent a mix of praise and critique, noting its blend of humor and emotional depth. Many praise the strong ensemble cast, especially standoutperformances from Sally Field, Shirley MacLaine, and Roberts – who bring charm and warmth to their roles. While some critics feel the film balances humor and heartfelt moments well, others argue that it overuses sentimentality and loses intimacy in its cinematic adaptation, occasionally leaning into superficial or exaggerated performances. With an abundance of comedy and lively characters,Steel Magnoliasarguably becomes more powerful and impactful when it leans into full melodrama at the end.
$15 million
$96.8 million
73%
Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
89%
Upon its release in 1989,Steel Magnoliaswas also a big box office success,grossing over six times its $15 million budget for a worldwide total of $96.8 million. The movie was also released on VHS in 1990 and DVD in 2000, allowing it to gross an additional $40 million, bringing its total gross to $135 million. Over the years, there have been numerous attempts to adapt Robert Harling’s stage play to different mediums and recapture this success, including a 1990 CBS sitcom pilot set after the events of the film and a 2012 Lifetime remake featuring an all-black cast.
The Lifetime remake stars Queen Latifah, Jill Scott, Alfre Woodard, Phylicia Rashād, Adepero Oduye, and Condola Rashād.
Needless to say, neither could recapture this success, as the pilot was not picked up to series and the Lifetime remake made little impact. Over 30 years later,Steel Magnoliasstill stands as an early testament to Julia Roberts' talent, who would later become one of Hollywood’s most bankable stars. Despite the harsh treatment she faced on the set ofSteel Magnolias, Roberts' performance marked a breakthrough, earning her first Oscar nomination and paving the way for three more forPretty Woman,Erin Brockovich, andAugust: Osage County.
Steel Magnolias
Cast
Steel Magnolias is a made-for-TV movie remake of the 1989 original, featuring an all-African American cast, including Queen Latifah, Phylicia Rashad, and Alfre Woodard. The film follows the story of a group of Southern women who gather at a small-town Louisiana beauty salon, where they share their lives, laughter, and tears, as they navigate love, loss, and life’s challenges together.
